The student news site of Dartmouth High School

The Spectrum

Filed under Opinion, Showcase

Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

SAN+PEDRO%2C+CA+-+SEPTEMBER+15%2C+2015%3A+Donald+Trump%2C+2016+Republican+presidential+candidate%2C+speaks+during+a+rally+aboard+the+Battleship+USS+Iowa+in+San+Pedro%2C+Los+Angeles%2C+California+while+wearing+a+red+baseball+hat+that+says+campaign+slogan+%22Make+America+Great+Again.%22
SAN PEDRO, CA - SEPTEMBER 15, 2015: Donald Trump, 2016 Republican presidential candidate, speaks during a rally aboard the Battleship USS Iowa in San Pedro, Los Angeles, California while wearing a red baseball hat that says campaign slogan

SAN PEDRO, CA - SEPTEMBER 15, 2015: Donald Trump, 2016 Republican presidential candidate, speaks during a rally aboard the Battleship USS Iowa in San Pedro, Los Angeles, California while wearing a red baseball hat that says campaign slogan "Make America Great Again."

Joseph Sohm

Joseph Sohm

SAN PEDRO, CA - SEPTEMBER 15, 2015: Donald Trump, 2016 Republican presidential candidate, speaks during a rally aboard the Battleship USS Iowa in San Pedro, Los Angeles, California while wearing a red baseball hat that says campaign slogan "Make America Great Again."

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






A sheriff is defined as an elected officer who is in charge of keeping peace in their assigned county. Our hometown sheriff Thomas Hodgson has been doing anything but keeping the peace recently, and has further stirred up our frazzled post-election town.

On January 4, at his fourth inaugural press conference, Hodgson offered President Trump the Bristol County inmates to help build Trump’s Mexican border wall. Hodgson’s plan has recently endured pushback in our state legislature, and has brought liberals and conservatives to yet another domestic battle: prisoners’ rights. Every human being deserves human rights, but these lines are blurred for some when a crime is committed.

It’s important to make one thing in this argument clear, however: the 13th amendment does indeed abolish slavery, but not for all American citizens. “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place subject to their jurisdiction.” In other words, it is legal for prisoners to be enslaved during their jail time, under the Constitution.

This brings us back to the local issue. MA State Rep. for New Bedford Antonio Cabral has come up with a bill that would amend the state law so it would be illegal for Massachusetts inmates to work outside the state.

“It’s not his responsibility nor does he have the authority to tell me how to manage my inmates,” said Hodgson in response to this bill. Many say that Hodgson’s idea could very well be slavery, but remember, this is legal under the US Constitution. While no, it is not morally correct in any way to own a slave or treat a human being as anything but a human being, it’s also not morally correct, in most situations, to break the law.

Then again, this is also the law that still allows slavery, so picking a side of the debate is difficult. Students here at DHS seem to represent both sides of this argument.

“It’s not like in the past how people were enslaved and abused because they were different. The Bristol County prisoners are being punished for a certain reason,” said sophomore Abby Arruda, in regards to people comparing Hodgson’s plan to a new form of slavery.

Many student opinions on Hodgson’s proposal have a lot to do with their opinion on Trump’s wall. “I think it’s ridiculous that the sheriff supports the construction of the wall, and I think it’s even more ridiculous that he’s trying to volunteer inmates to do this work against their will,”  said a sophomore.

Others, like Hodgson, believe that this idea could have a positive impact on the inmates and could be an effective use of free labor. Hodgson named his proposal Project NICE (National Inmates’ Community Endeavors), which is meant to help rehabilitate inmates.

“Aside from learning and perfecting construction skills, the symbolism of these inmates building a wall to prevent crime in communities around the country can be very powerful,” said Hodgson.

“I think it’s a good idea so the inmates can have a purpose in life, and give back to society,” said sophomore Taenlar Tavares.

It does not look like Hodgson’s proposal will make any actual progress. Multiple organizations and civil rights activists including the ACLU, US Representative Joseph P. Kennedy III, and others have spoken out against Hodgson.

“Its likely an attempt by Sheriff Hodgson just to ride this wave and become famous nationally,” said staff counsel with the Massachusetts ACLU, Laura Rótolo.

Print Friendly

2 Comments

2 Responses to “Sheriff Hodgson and the wall”

  1. Jack D'Atri on February 8th, 2017 8:57 pm

    Sheriff Hodgson’s plan is brilliant! This is a great way to lower the cost of the wall (until Mexico reimburses us, of course) and, as the sheriff said, will benefit the prisoners too. The wall will stop illegal aliens, which is its main purpose. Obviously, the “wall” will not just be physical; it will extend to newer technologies and protocols for stopping illegal aliens. Anyone who says “no human being is illegal” is a fool. America is a country of laws. If people choose not to follow the law, they do not belong here. Illegal aliens broke the law as soon as they entered the country ILLEGALLY.

    I’m going to show you a Trump quote now:

    “We are a nation of immigrants.. but we are a nation of laws

    Our nation is rightly disturbed by the large numbers of illegal aliens entering our country…

    Illegal immigrants take jobs from citizens or legal immigrants, they impose burdens on our taxpayers…

    That is why we are doubling the number of border guards, deporting more illegal immigrants than ever before, cracking down on illegal hiring, barring benefits to illegal aliens, and we will do more to speed the deportation of illegal immigrants arrest for crimes…

    It is wrong and ultimately self-defeating for a nation of immigrants to permit the kind of abuse of our immigration laws that has occurred in the last few years.. and we must do more to stop it.”

    [Standing Ovation]

    Just kidding. Bill Clinton said this in 1996.

    [Reply]

  2. Jack D'Atri on February 8th, 2017 9:04 pm

    Also, the “ACLU” is a bunch of bleeding-heart crybabies

    [Reply]

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Kettle Logic

    Kettle Logic

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Showcase

    Mr. Dartmouth: It’s all about the talent

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Showcase

    Winter guard through the eyes of an indoor percussion performer

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Showcase

    Indoor percussion through the eyes of a winter guard performer

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Showcase

    Sticky note mastermind speaks

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Reductio Ad Absurdum

    Kettle Logic

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    News

    College Acceptance Wall: Moved to the Guidance Office

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    News

    Search is on: What does DHS want in a new principal?

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    News

    Memorial Stadium set to be renovated

  • Sheriff Hodgson and the wall

    Opinion

    Kettle Logic

The student news site of Dartmouth High School
Sheriff Hodgson and the wall